| Most Seasons Over .500 | |
|---|---|
| Team | Seasons |
| Bree Cheese | 37 |
| Bucklebury Fairies | 32 |
| Minas Morgul Slayers | 32 |
| Old Forest Merry Fellows | 30 |
| Ravenhill Darkwings | 29 |
| Misty Mountain Hops | 29 |
| Isengard Raiders | 29 |
| Mirkwood Sylvan | 28 |
| Bywater Bounders | 27 |
| Lothlorien Lumberjacks | 26 |
| Dead Marshes Uruk-hai | 21 |
| Grey Havens Stars | 21 |
| Rivendell Royals | 20 |
| Moria Miners | 20 |
| Lake Town Archers | 20 |