| Most Games out of First | ||
|---|---|---|
| Team | Year | GB |
| Windy City Blues | 2026 | 68 |
| Syracuse Snappers | 2038 | 66 |
| California Wildfire | 1981 | 66 |
| Carolina Tobs | 2050 | 64 |
| Phoenix Roadrunners | 2027 | 63 |
| Montreal Exports | 2023 | 63 |
| Pawtucket Patriots | 2006 | 61 |
| Toronto Canadians | 2013 | 61 |
| Wilmington Wildcats | 2013 | 61 |
| Montreal Exports | 2035 | 60 |
| Pittsburgh Millers | 1979 | 59 |
| Toronto Canadians | 2054 | 59 |
| Virginia Colonials | 1982 | 59 |
| Wilmington Wildcats | 1991 | 59 |
| Wilmington Blue Wave | 2005 | 58 |